2024 Regular SessionIndiana Legislature

SB0202: State educational institution matters.

Legislative Summary

State educational institution matters. Amends the duties of state educational institutions' diversity committees. Provides that certain offices or individuals established or employed by a state educational institution (institution) regarding diversity programming must include within the mission of the office or position programming that substantially promotes both cultural and intellectual diversity. Establishes various requirements and restrictions for institutions regarding free inquiry, free expression, and intellectual diversity that does the following: (1) Requires the establishment of certain policies regarding: (A) disciplinary actions for certain persons that materially and substantially disrupt protected expressive activity; (B) limiting or restricting the granting of tenure or a promotion if certain conditions related to free inquiry, free expression, and intellectual diversity are not met; and (C) disciplinary actions that will be taken if, after a review, a determination has been made that a tenured faculty member has failed to meet certain criteria related to free inquiry, free expression, and intellectual diversity. (2) Requires the review and consideration, at least every five years, of certain criteria related to free inquiry, free expression, and intellectual diversity. (3) Requires the establishment of a procedure that allows students and employees to submit complaints that a faculty member or contractor is not meeting certain criteria related to free inquiry, free expression, and intellectual diversity and establishes requirements regarding the procedure and submitted complaints. (4) Establishes consideration requirements before an institution renews an employment agreement or other contract with, makes a bonus decision regarding, or completes a review or performance assessment of a faculty member or contractor. (5) Prohibits requiring an applicant, employee, or contractor to pledge allegiance to or make a statement of personal support for: (A) certain policies or actions; or (B) political or ideological movements. (6) Establishes restrictions regarding awarding admission, enrollment, employment, benefits, hiring, reappointment, promotion, or granting tenure to an applicant, employee, or contractor on the basis of the viewpoints expressed in a submitted pledge or statement. (7) Requires certain information be included in an institution's programming for new students. (8) Requires the adoption of a statement on neutrality that makes a distinction between the official positions of an institution from the individual viewpoints of the institution's employees, contractors, students, and alumni. (9) Allows the commission for higher education (commission) to establish a survey that attempts to collect information from students regarding the current perceptions of whether free speech and academic freedom are recognized and fostered by an institution in a manner that welcomes expression of different opinions and ideologies and requires an institution to promote and provide the survey to students. (10) Establishes various reporting requirements by institutions or the commission concerning complaints submitted regarding faculty members or contractors who are not meeting certain criteria related to free inquiry, free expression, and intellectual diversity. (11) Provides that certain individuals may request the commission to review a final decision by an institution concerning a violation of these provisions. Provides that the commission may enter into an agreement with the office of administrative law proceedings to review violations of certain provisions and issue an opinion on behalf of the commission. Requires each institution to submit certain information by September 1, 2024, and on September 1 of each year thereafter.

Bill History

1/9/2024
Authored by Senators Deery, Raatz and Johnson T
Senate
1/9/2024
First reading: referred to Committee on Education and Career Development
Senate
1/18/2024
Senator Byrne added as coauthor
Senate
1/25/2024
Committee report: amend do pass, adopted
Senate
2/1/2024
Senators Donato, Crane, Rogers added as coauthors
Senate
2/5/2024
Amendment #14 (Deery) prevailed; voice vote
Senate
2/5/2024
Amendment #15 (Deery) prevailed; Division of the Senate: yeas 34, nays 8
Senate
2/5/2024
Amendment #11 (Goode) prevailed; voice vote
Senate
2/5/2024
Amendment #7 (Qaddoura) failed; Roll Call 94: yeas 8, nays 40
Senate
2/5/2024
Amendment #6 (Qaddoura) failed; Roll Call 95: yeas 8, nays 40
Senate
2/5/2024
Amendment #5 (Qaddoura) failed; Roll Call 96: yeas 7, nays 40
Senate
2/5/2024
Amendment #2 (Ford J.D.) failed; Roll Call 97: yeas 9, nays 39
Senate
2/5/2024
Amendment #3 (Ford J.D.) failed; Roll Call 98: yeas 8, nays 40
Senate
2/5/2024
Second reading: amended, ordered engrossed
Senate
2/6/2024
Third reading: passed; Roll Call 131: yeas 39, nays 9
Senate
2/6/2024
House sponsor: Representative Behning
Senate
2/6/2024
Cosponsors: Representatives Davis, Teshka, Heaton
Senate
2/7/2024
Referred to the House
Senate
2/12/2024
First reading: referred to Committee on Education
House of Representatives
2/22/2024
Minority report (DeLaney) not substituted for majority report Roll Call 183: yeas 28, nays 58
House of Representatives
2/22/2024
Committee report: amend do pass, adopted Roll Call 184: yeas 59, nays 28
House of Representatives
2/22/2024
Referred to Committee on Ways and Means pursuant to House Rule 84; Failed, Roll Call 185: yeas 28, nays 59
House of Representatives
2/26/2024
Amendment #1 (Behning) prevailed; voice vote
House of Representatives
2/26/2024
Amendment #2 (Smith V) failed; Roll Call 199: yeas 31, nays 62
House of Representatives
2/26/2024
Amendment #3 (DeLaney) failed; Roll Call 200: yeas 29, nays 63
House of Representatives
2/26/2024
Amendment #4 (DeLaney) failed; Roll Call 201: yeas 36, nays 58
House of Representatives
2/26/2024
Second reading: amended, ordered engrossed
House of Representatives
2/27/2024
Third reading: passed; Roll Call 227: yeas 66, nays 31
House of Representatives
2/28/2024
Returned to the Senate with amendments
House of Representatives
2/28/2024
Motion to concur filed
Senate
2/29/2024
Senate concurred in House amendments; Roll Call 242: yeas 33, nays 12
Senate
3/5/2024
Signed by the President Pro Tempore
Senate
3/7/2024
Signed by the Speaker
House of Representatives
3/8/2024
Signed by the President of the Senate
Senate
3/13/2024
Signed by the Governor
Senate
3/13/2024
Public Law 113
Senate

Amendments

House Amendment #4

House Amendment #4

2/26/2024Not Adopted

House Amendment #1

House Amendment #1

2/26/2024Adopted

House Amendment #2

House Amendment #2

2/26/2024Not Adopted

House Amendment #3

House Amendment #3

2/26/2024Not Adopted

House Education Amendment #18

House Education Amendment #18

2/21/2024Not Adopted

House Education Amendment #10

House Education Amendment #10

2/21/2024Not Adopted

House Education Amendment #16

House Education Amendment #16

2/21/2024Not Adopted

House Education Amendment #17

House Education Amendment #17

2/21/2024Not Adopted

House Education Amendment #22

House Education Amendment #22

2/21/2024Not Adopted

House Education Amendment #23

House Education Amendment #23

2/21/2024Not Adopted

House Education Amendment #24

House Education Amendment #24

2/21/2024Not Adopted

House Education Amendment #25

House Education Amendment #25

2/21/2024Not Adopted

House Education Amendment #21

House Education Amendment #21

2/21/2024Not Adopted

House Education Amendment #19

House Education Amendment #19

2/20/2024Not Adopted

House Education Amendment #15

House Education Amendment #15

2/13/2024Not Adopted

House Education Amendment #12

House Education Amendment #12

2/13/2024Not Adopted

House Education Amendment #10

House Education Amendment #10

2/13/2024Not Adopted

Senate Amendment #15

Senate Amendment #15

2/5/2024Adopted

Senate Amendment #16

Senate Amendment #16

2/5/2024Not Adopted

Senate Amendment #14

Senate Amendment #14

2/5/2024Adopted

Senate Amendment #12

Senate Amendment #12

2/1/2024Not Adopted

Senate Amendment #13

Senate Amendment #13

2/1/2024Not Adopted

Senate Amendment #11

Senate Amendment #11

1/31/2024Not Adopted

Senate Amendment #10

Senate Amendment #10

1/30/2024Not Adopted

Senate Amendment #4

Senate Amendment #4

1/29/2024Not Adopted

Senate Amendment #5

Senate Amendment #5

1/29/2024Not Adopted

Senate Amendment #6

Senate Amendment #6

1/29/2024Not Adopted

Senate Amendment #7

Senate Amendment #7

1/29/2024Not Adopted

Senate Amendment #9

Senate Amendment #9

1/29/2024Not Adopted

Senate Amendment #8

Senate Amendment #8

1/29/2024Not Adopted

Senate Amendment #1

Senate Amendment #1

1/29/2024Not Adopted

Senate Amendment #2

Senate Amendment #2

1/29/2024Not Adopted

Senate Amendment #3

Senate Amendment #3

1/29/2024Not Adopted

Senate Education and Career Development Amendment #8

Senate Education and Career Development Amendment #8

1/24/2024Not Adopted

Senate Education and Career Development Amendment #9

Senate Education and Career Development Amendment #9

1/24/2024Not Adopted

Senate Education and Career Development Amendment #7

Senate Education and Career Development Amendment #7

1/23/2024Not Adopted

Senate Education and Career Development Amendment #6

Senate Education and Career Development Amendment #6

1/23/2024Not Adopted

Roll Call Votes

Senate - Senate concurred in House amendments
2/29/2024
33
Yea
12
Nay
4
Not Voting
1
Absent
Result: PASSED
House - Third reading
2/27/2024
67
Yea
30
Nay
1
Not Voting
2
Absent
Result: PASSED
House - Amendment #2 (Smith V) failed
2/26/2024
31
Yea
62
Nay
3
Not Voting
4
Absent
Result: FAILED
House - Amendment #4 (DeLaney) failed
2/26/2024
36
Yea
58
Nay
2
Not Voting
4
Absent
Result: FAILED
House - Amendment #3 (DeLaney) failed
2/26/2024
29
Yea
63
Nay
2
Not Voting
6
Absent
Result: FAILED
House - Referred to Committee on Ways and Means pursuant to House Rule 84
2/22/2024
28
Yea
59
Nay
2
Not Voting
11
Absent
Result: FAILED
House - Minority report (DeLaney) not substituted for majority report
2/22/2024
28
Yea
58
Nay
2
Not Voting
12
Absent
Result: FAILED
House - Committee report
2/22/2024
59
Yea
28
Nay
2
Not Voting
11
Absent
Result: PASSED
Senate - Third reading
2/6/2024
39
Yea
9
Nay
0
Not Voting
2
Absent
Result: PASSED
Senate - Amendment #7 (Qaddoura) failed
2/5/2024
8
Yea
40
Nay
0
Not Voting
2
Absent
Result: FAILED
Senate - Amendment #2 (Ford J.D.) failed
2/5/2024
9
Yea
39
Nay
0
Not Voting
2
Absent
Result: FAILED
Senate - Amendment #3 (Ford J.D.) failed
2/5/2024
8
Yea
40
Nay
0
Not Voting
2
Absent
Result: FAILED
Senate - Amendment #5 (Qaddoura) failed
2/5/2024
7
Yea
40
Nay
1
Not Voting
2
Absent
Result: FAILED
Senate - Amendment #6 (Qaddoura) failed
2/5/2024
8
Yea
40
Nay
0
Not Voting
2
Absent
Result: FAILED

Status Information

Current Status
Passed(3/13/2024)
Chamber
Senate
Sine DiePrior Session

Documents

Enrolled
Bill Text3/1/2024238.7 KB
Engrossed
Bill Text2/26/2024661.3 KB
Comm Sub
Bill Text2/22/2024635.2 KB
Engrossed
Bill Text2/5/2024824.8 KB
Comm Sub
Bill Text1/25/2024449.9 KB
Introduced
Bill Text1/9/2024239.7 KB
Fiscal Note
Fiscal Note3/1/202473.6 KB
Fiscal Note
Fiscal Note2/27/202473.6 KB
Fiscal Note
Fiscal Note2/26/202473.7 KB
Fiscal Note
Fiscal Note2/22/202471.9 KB
Misc
Misc2/22/202462.0 KB
Misc
Misc2/22/202465.8 KB
Misc
Misc2/21/202424.8 KB
Fiscal Note
Fiscal Note2/6/202475.4 KB
Fiscal Note
Fiscal Note2/5/202475.5 KB
Fiscal Note
Fiscal Note1/26/202475.7 KB
Misc
Misc1/25/202487.1 KB
Misc
Misc1/24/202422.0 KB
Fiscal Note
Fiscal Note1/9/202472.6 KB