2023 Regular SessionVirginia Legislature

HB2129: Child victims and witnesses; using two-way closed-circuit television, expands age range.

Legislative Summary

Child victims and witnesses using two-way closed-circuit television; standard. Expands the age range that a child may testify using two-way closed-circuit television in a criminal case to any child younger than 18 years of age at the time of the trial. Under current law, an alleged victim must be 14 years of age or younger at the time of the alleged offense and 16 years of age or younger at the time of the trial and a child witness must be 14 years of age or younger at the time of the trial to testify by two-way closed-circuit television. The bill also provides that the court may order that the testimony of a child be taken by closed-circuit television if it finds that the child is unavailable to testify in open court in the presence of the defendant, the jury, the judge, and the public if the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, based upon expert opinion testimony, that the child will suffer emotional trauma that is more than de minimis as a result of testifying in the defendant's presence and not the courtroom generally. Under current law, the court may order such testimony be taken by closed-circuit television if there is a substantial likelihood, based upon expert opinion testimony, that the child will suffer severe emotional trauma from so testifying. Child victims and witnesses using two-way closed-circuit television; standard. Expands the age range that a child may testify using two-way closed-circuit television in a criminal case to any child younger than 18 years of age at the time of the trial. Under current law, an alleged victim must be 14 years of age or younger at the time of the alleged offense and 16 years of age or younger at the time of the trial and a child witness must be 14 years of age or younger at the time of the trial to testify by two-way closed-circuit television. The bill also provides that the court may order that the testimony of a child be taken by closed-circuit television if it finds that the child is unavailable to testify in open court in the presence of the defendant, the jury, the judge, and the public if the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, based upon expert opinion testimony, that the child will suffer emotional trauma that is more than de minimis as a result of testifying in the defendant's presence and not the courtroom generally. Under current law, the court may order such testimony be taken by closed-circuit television if there is a substantial likelihood, based upon expert opinion testimony, that the child will suffer severe emotional trauma from so testifying.

Bill History

1/10/2023
Prefiled and ordered printed; offered 01/11/23 23103472D
House of Delegates
1/10/2023
Referred to Committee for Courts of Justice
House of Delegates
1/19/2023
Assigned Courts sub: Subcommittee #1
House of Delegates
1/23/2023
Subcommittee recommends reporting with substitute (8-Y 0-N)
House of Delegates
1/27/2023
Reported from Courts of Justice with substitute (20-Y 0-N)
House of Delegates
1/27/2023
Committee substitute printed 23105150D-H1
House of Delegates
1/27/2023
Referred to Committee on Appropriations
House of Delegates
1/27/2023
Assigned App. sub: Transportation & Public Safety
House of Delegates
1/30/2023
Subcommittee recommends reporting (8-Y 0-N)
House of Delegates
1/30/2023
Reported from Appropriations (22-Y 0-N)
House of Delegates
2/1/2023
Read first time
House of Delegates
2/2/2023
Read second time
House of Delegates
2/2/2023
Committee substitute agreed to 23105150D-H1
House of Delegates
2/2/2023
Engrossed by House - committee substitute HB2129H1
House of Delegates
2/3/2023
Read third time and passed House BLOCK VOTE (99-Y 0-N)
House of Delegates
2/3/2023
VOTE: Block Vote Passage (99-Y 0-N)
House of Delegates
2/6/2023
Constitutional reading dispensed
Senate
2/6/2023
Referred to Committee on the Judiciary
Senate
2/15/2023
Reported from Judiciary with substitute (10-Y 5-N)
Senate
2/15/2023
Committee substitute printed 23107007D-S1
Senate
2/15/2023
Rereferred to Finance and Appropriations
Senate
2/16/2023
Reported from Finance and Appropriations with amendment (13-Y 3-N)
Senate
2/20/2023
Constitutional reading dispensed (40-Y 0-N)
Senate
2/21/2023
Read third time
Senate
2/21/2023
Reading of substitute waived
Senate
2/21/2023
Committee substitute agreed to 23107007D-S1
Senate
2/21/2023
Reading of amendment waived
Senate
2/21/2023
Committee amendment agreed to
Senate
2/21/2023
Passed by for the day
Senate
2/22/2023
Passed by for the day
Senate
2/23/2023
Read third time
Senate
2/23/2023
Passed by temporarily
Senate
2/23/2023
Reading of Surovell amendment waived
Senate
2/23/2023
Amendment by Senator Surovell withdrawn
Senate
2/23/2023
Reading of Boysko amendments waived
Senate
2/23/2023
Amendments by Senator Boysko rejected (10-Y 29-N)
Senate
2/23/2023
Passed by temporarily
Senate
2/23/2023
Reading of amendment waived
Senate
2/23/2023
Amendment by Senator Surovell agreed to
Senate
2/23/2023
Engrossed by Senate - committee substitute with amendments HB2129S1
Senate
2/23/2023
Passed Senate with substitute with amendments (39-Y 0-N)
Senate
2/23/2023
Senate substitute with amendments rejected by House 23107007D-S1 (0-Y 85-N)
House of Delegates
2/23/2023
VOTE: Adoption (0-Y 85-N)
House of Delegates
2/23/2023
Senate insisted on substitute with amendments (37-Y 0-N)
Senate
2/23/2023
Senate requested conference committee
Senate
2/23/2023
House acceded to request
House of Delegates
2/23/2023
Conferees appointed by House
House of Delegates
2/23/2023
Delegates: Delaney, Bell, Ballard
House of Delegates
2/23/2023
Conferees appointed by Senate
Senate
2/23/2023
Senators: Surovell, Morrissey, Norment
Senate
2/25/2023
No further action taken
House of Delegates
2/25/2023
Failed to pass in House
House of Delegates

Amendments

Senate amendments engrossed

Senate amendments engrossed

2/23/2023Not Adopted

Senate amendments not adopted

Senate amendments not adopted

2/23/2023Adopted

Amendment(s) for HB2129 for S-Finance and Appropriations

Amendment(s) for HB2129 for S-Finance and Appropriations

2/16/2023Not Adopted

Substitute for HB2129 Courts of Justice, Subcommittee #1

Substitute for HB2129 Courts of Justice, Subcommittee #1

1/23/2023Not Adopted

Substitute for HB2129 Courts of Justice, Subcommittee #1

Substitute for HB2129 Courts of Justice, Subcommittee #1

1/23/2023Adopted

Senate amendments

Senate amendments

12/17/2017Not Adopted

Roll Call Votes

House: VOTE: Adoption (0-Y 85-N)
2/23/2023
0
Yea
85
Nay
0
Not Voting
15
Absent
Result: FAILED
Senate: Senate insisted on substitute with amendments (37-Y 0-N)
2/23/2023
37
Yea
0
Nay
0
Not Voting
3
Absent
Result: PASSED
Senate: Passed Senate with substitute with amendments (39-Y 0-N)
2/23/2023
39
Yea
0
Nay
0
Not Voting
1
Absent
Result: PASSED
Senate: Amendments by Senator Boysko rejected (10-Y 29-N)
2/23/2023
10
Yea
29
Nay
0
Not Voting
1
Absent
Result: FAILED
Senate: Constitutional reading dispensed (40-Y 0-N)
2/20/2023
40
Yea
0
Nay
0
Not Voting
0
Absent
Result: PASSED
Senate: Reported from Finance and Appropriations with amendment (13-Y 3-N)
2/16/2023
13
Yea
3
Nay
0
Not Voting
0
Absent
Result: PASSED
Senate: Reported from Judiciary with substitute (10-Y 5-N)
2/15/2023
10
Yea
5
Nay
0
Not Voting
0
Absent
Result: PASSED
House: VOTE: Block Vote Passage (99-Y 0-N)
2/3/2023
99
Yea
0
Nay
0
Not Voting
1
Absent
Result: PASSED
House: Reported from Appropriations (22-Y 0-N)
1/30/2023
22
Yea
0
Nay
0
Not Voting
0
Absent
Result: PASSED
House: Subcommittee recommends reporting (8-Y 0-N)
1/30/2023
8
Yea
0
Nay
0
Not Voting
0
Absent
Result: PASSED
House: Reported from Courts of Justice with substitute (20-Y 0-N)
1/27/2023
20
Yea
0
Nay
0
Not Voting
0
Absent
Result: PASSED
House: Subcommittee recommends reporting with substitute (8-Y 0-N)
1/23/2023
8
Yea
0
Nay
0
Not Voting
0
Absent
Result: PASSED

Status Information

Current Status
Failed(2/25/2023)
Chamber
House of Delegates
Sine DiePrior Session

Documents

Comm Sub
Bill Text2/15/20234.5 KB
Comm Sub
Bill Text1/27/20234.5 KB
Prefiled
Bill Text1/10/20234.6 KB
Fiscal Note/Analysis
Fiscal Note/Analysis2/22/202367.7 KB
Fiscal Note/Analysis
Fiscal Note/Analysis1/30/202367.3 KB